Which is louder?
Lost Cherry 60Cherry Smoothie 2022 46Lost Cherry throws further and holds its cherry cloud; Cherry Smoothie stays closer and thins out sooner.
Which is more recognizable?
Lost Cherry gets clocked as "that cherry" more often; Cherry Smoothie reads as a generic sweet cherry, no address.
Where can you wear it?
Neither is office wear; Lost Cherry survives the evening, Cherry Smoothie fades before the night warms up.
How similar they are
Scent100%
On paper it's the same liquid: cherry-almond-tonka-plum-balsam met note for note.
Vibe14%
Yet they wear like strangers: Lost Cherry boozy and dimensional, Cherry Smoothie flat-sweet. The paper twin is a stranger in real life.
What they share — and where they split
shared · 6cherryalmondtonka beanvanillaplumperu balsam
Then they split:
Lost Cherrycherry blossomrosecinnamonbenzoin
Cherry Smoothie 2022heliotropehawthorn
They share the whole spine — cherry, almond, tonka, vanilla, plum, peru balsam; Lost Cherry adds cherry blossom, rose, cinnamon and benzoin for liqueur depth, Cherry Smoothie swaps in heliotrope and hawthorn for a simpler candy.
Lost Cherry in 2018 launched the gourmand-cherry craze; Cherry Smoothie in 2022 is the mass echo that rode it.
Tom Ford niche against affordable Zara — the accord copies, but the liqueur booze and the long finish are what the niche signature actually delivers here.
Lost Cherry is still the more searched name; the dupe rides on it.